A new research study presents evidence that providing blue light-filtering glasses to employees may be an unusually practical solution for improving employee sleep, productivity and work outcomes. What’s most impressive about the results is the potential return on investment. It’s difficult to quantify the value of an employee who is 8% more engaged, 17% higher in helping behavior, 12% lower in negative work behavior, and 8% higher in task performance. However, given the expense of human capital, this is likely to be a substantial amount. In contrast to these highly valuable outcomes, the glasses used in the study currently retail for $69.00, and there may be other equivalently effective brands of glasses which can lead to similar outcomes. Such a small expense for such a substantial return is likely to be an unusually fruitful investment. Moreover, implementation of this solution is relatively simple: distribute the glasses along with some simple instructions for how to use them, why the glasses should work, and how the end result is beneficial for both employee health and work outcomes.
You want your employees to be the best versions of themselves at work. My research indicates that making sleep a priority is one important place to focus your efforts. Getting enough sleep can be an effective way of enhancing a broad array of work outcomes, including work engagement, ethical behavior, spotting good ideas, and leadership. If you want the best versions of your employees, you should want them to get full nights of high-quality sleep.
But how do you implement this change in behavior? Your employees sleep at home; you can’t be there with them and force them to sleep more. They may be facing issues over which you have no control, like family responsibilities, medical conditions, and other jobs. You can try putting employees in positions that might make getting enough sleep more likely, like implementing sleep-friendly work schedules and keeping workloads from getting too heavy. These are only partial solutions, however, and may not practical to implement when there is pressure to keep payroll costs low. You can also look for opportunities to match employees who have problems sleeping with resources to treat those sleep difficulties. This can work well, but requires additional financial commitments to employee health care.
So, the question remains: Is it possible to have a low-cost, easy-to-implement solution for enhancing employee effectiveness by improving employee sleep? (Spoiler alert: the answer is yes, with one such example costing $69 per employee.)
My colleagues and I conducted a forthcoming research study focused on this question. We built upon previous research which shows that wearing glasses that filter out blue light can help people sleep better. The reasons for this are a bit technical, but the gist is that melatonin is a biochemical that enhances the propensity for sleep and tends to rise in the evening before bedtime. Exposure to light suppresses the production of melatonin, making it more difficult to fall asleep. But not all light has the same effect — and blue light has the strongest effect. So, filtering out blue light eliminates much of the suppressing effect of light on melatonin production, allowing the evening increase in melatonin to occur and thereby enabling the process of falling asleep.
Based upon that research, as well as my own previous research linking sleep to work outcomes, my colleagues and I took the next step to examine the effect of wearing blue light filtering glasses on work outcomes. In a set of two studies of employees working in Brazil, we examined a broad set of work outcomes, including work engagement, helping behavior, negative work behaviors (such as mistreating others as work), and task performance.
The first study examined 63 managers, and the second study examined 67 customer service representatives. Both studies used the same research design: The employees spent one week wearing blue light filtering glasses for two hours before bedtime each night for a week. The same employees also spent one week wearing “sham” glasses for two hours before bedtime each night. The sham glasses had the same frames, but the lenses did not filter out blue light. Participants had no reason to believe that there would be differential effects of the two sets of glasses on sleep or performance, or in which direction such an effect would occur. We randomly determined whether any given participant spent the first week using the blue light filtering glasses or the sham glasses.
The results were remarkably consistent across the two studies. Compared to the week in which people wore the sham glasses, in the week in which people wore the blue-light-filtering glasses participants reported sleeping more (5% longer in the managers study, and 6% longer in the customer service representative study) and getting higher quality sleep (14% better in the managers study, and 11% better in the customer service representative study).
Sleep quantity and quality both had beneficial effects on all four work outcomes. Compared to the week in which participants wore the sham glasses, in the week in which people wore the blue light filtering glasses, participants reported higher work engagement (8.51% higher in the managers study and 8.25% higher in the customer service representative study), more helping behavior (17.29% and 17.82% more in each study, respectively), and fewer negative work behaviors (11.78% and 11.76% fewer, respectively).
In the manager study, participants reported their own performance as 7.11% higher when wearing blue light filtering glasses compared to when wearing the sham glasses. But the task performance results are most compelling for the customer service representative study. In the customer service representative study, customer evaluations for each employee were averaged across the workday. Compared to when the customer service employees wore the sham glasses, wearing the blue-light-filtering glasses led to an increase of 9% in customer service ratings.
In short, the blue light filtering glasses improved both sleep and work outcomes.
What’s most impressive about these results is the implied return on investment. It’s difficult to quantify the value of an employee who is 8% more engaged, 17% higher in helping behavior, 12% lower in negative work behavior, and 8% higher in task performance. However, given the expense of human capital, this is likely to be a substantial amount.
In the study of customer service employees, for example, the measure of task performance was customer ratings of their satisfaction with the service, which is an especially critical outcome. In contrast to these highly valuable outcomes, these particular glasses currently retail for $69.00, and there may be other equivalently effective brands of glasses that can lead to similar outcomes (do your research, though — some glasses are much more effective than others). Such a small expense for such a substantial return is likely to be an unusually fruitful investment.
As sleep and circadian science continues to advance, there will likely be more avenues to apply sleep health interventions that result in beneficial work outcomes. Employees and organizations will eventually have a potent menu of options for enhancing employee sleep, to everyone’s benefit. But blue light filtering glasses are an appealing initial step because they are easy to implement, noninvasive, and — as our research shows — effective.